Traditional vs Alternative Protein Sources (Insects, Plant-Based Proteins, Lab-Grown Meat)

April 18, 2022

Traditional vs Alternative Protein Sources: An Unbiased Comparison

As the world population continues to grow and the demand for protein increases, the traditional sources of protein like meat, fish, and dairy are becoming less sustainable. This has led to the rise of alternative protein sources like insects, plant-based proteins, and lab-grown meat. In this blog post, we will compare the nutritional value, sustainability, and ethical considerations of these protein sources to help you make an informed decision.

Nutritional Value

Protein is an essential nutrient that helps build and repair body tissues. It's also important for maintaining muscle mass, immune function, and hormone balance. Here’s how the traditional and alternative protein sources compare in terms of nutritional value:

Meat: Meat is a rich source of complete proteins, essential amino acids, iron, and vitamin B12. However, it's also high in cholesterol and saturated fats, which can increase the risk of heart disease.
Fish: Fish is a good source of complete proteins, omega-3 fatty acids, and vitamin D. It's also low in saturated fats and cholesterol. However, overfishing and pollution have made fish less sustainable.
Dairy: Dairy products like milk, cheese, and yogurt are a good source of protein, calcium, and vitamin D. However, they are also high in saturated fats and cholesterol, and not suitable for individuals who are lactose intolerant.
Insects: Insects like crickets, mealworms, and grasshoppers are a rich source of complete proteins, essential amino acids, and micronutrients like iron and zinc. They are also low in fat and have a high feed conversion rate.
Plant-based proteins: Plant-based proteins like beans, lentils, and peas are a great source of protein, fiber, and micronutrients like iron and zinc. They are also low in fat and cholesterol-free.
Lab-grown meat: Lab-grown meat is a good source of protein, and its nutritional value is similar to traditional meat. However, it's still a new technology, and studies are still ongoing to determine its long-term effects on health.

Sustainability

The traditional sources of protein like meat, fish, and dairy are associated with a high carbon footprint, water consumption, and deforestation. Therefore, alternative protein sources like insects, plant-based proteins, and lab-grown meat are being considered as more sustainable options. Here’s how they compare:

Meat: The meat industry is responsible for 18% of global greenhouse gas emissions, and it requires a lot of water and land to produce.
Fish: Overfishing has caused a decline in fish populations, and fish farming can lead to environmental pollution.
Dairy: The dairy industry has a high carbon footprint and water consumption.
Insects: Insects have a high feed conversion rate and require less land, water, and feed to produce. They also produce fewer greenhouse gases and waste products.
Plant-based proteins: Plant-based proteins require fewer resources to produce and have a low carbon footprint. They also don't contribute to deforestation.
Lab-grown meat: Lab-grown meat has the potential to reduce the environmental impact of meat production, as it requires fewer resources and produces fewer greenhouse gas emissions.

Ethical Considerations

Finally, there are ethical considerations to be made when it comes to protein sources. This includes animal welfare, labor practices, and cultural considerations. Here’s how the different protein sources compare:

Meat: The production of meat has been associated with animal cruelty, inhumane practices, and the use of antibiotics and growth hormones.
Fish: The fish industry has been associated with unethical labor practices and overfishing in some areas.
Dairy: The dairy industry has been associated with animal cruelty, including the separation of calves from their mothers.
Insects: Insects are often seen as a more ethical alternative to traditional animal protein sources, as they don't have the same capacity for suffering.
Plant-based proteins: Plant-based proteins are also seen as a more ethical alternative, as they don't require the use of animals.
Lab-grown meat: Some argue that lab-grown meat is more ethical, as it doesn't involve raising and slaughtering animals. Others argue that it could have unintended consequences for animal welfare in the long run.

Conclusion

There are a variety of protein sources available, and each has its own advantages and disadvantages in terms of nutritional value, sustainability, and ethical considerations. Ultimately, the choice of protein source depends on personal preference, culture, and dietary restrictions.

Stay aware of the nutritional value, sustainability, and ethical considerations of the protein sources you consume. The Flare Compare team hopes that this comparison helped you understand the traditional and alternative protein sources' differences better.

References:

Gustavsson, J., Cederberg, C., Sonesson, U., van Otterdijk, R., & Meybeck, A. (2011). Global food losses and food waste : extent, causes and prevention.
Halloran, A., Roos, N., & Eilenberg, J. (2015). BUGS as a sustainable source of protein in the future. Animal Frontiers, 5(2), 32–38.
Lynch, H., Johnston, C., & Wharton, C. (2018). Plant-based diets: Considerations for environmental impact, protein quality, and exercise performance. Nutrients, 10(12), 1841.
Mattick, C. S., Landis, A. E., Allenby, B. R., Genovese, N. J., & Carpenter, J. A. (2015). Anticipatory life cycle analysis of in vitro biomass cultivation for cultured meat production in the United States. Environmental Science & Technology, 49(19), 11941–11949.
Shepon, A., Eshel, G., Noor, E., & Milo, R. (2016). The opportunity cost of animal based diets exceeds all food losses. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 113(48), 13508–13513.